Reports & Research

The Alliance has compiled some of the most useful information about the cookstoves and fuels sectors to populate this searchable database, including market assessments, consumer behavior and preference information, and other research studies. The database will be updated frequently as we continue to build our knowledge database, and as always we appreciate our partners’ input. If you have any reports or research to add to this database, please send it to knowledge@cleancookstoves.org

Year
Language
Country
 
Stove Performance Inventory
Alliance Reports and Research, Cookstove Technology, Environment, Other | | Released on October 18, 2012

Across the sector, there has been widespread consensus on the need for a comprehensive and transparent understanding of how current technologies and fuels perform in the laboratory and field. Building from this aspiration and several recommendations from the Alliance working group process (Standards and Testing, Monitoring and Evaluation, Climate, and Carbon Finance), the Alliance has released a detailed inventory of stove and fuel performance, including emissions, indoor air pollution, efficiency, fuel use, and other metrics from a range of laboratory- and field-based protocols.

This Stove Performance Inventory, developed by the Berkeley Air Monitoring Group in partnership with the Alliance, contains data from over 600 sets of performance tests. A detailed report is available in the Resources section of the Alliance’s website, which describes:

• The stove and fuel types and geographical regions included in the inventory;
• Systematic survey process;
• Database framework;
• Analysis of the data; and
• Implications for international guidelines and standards, the carbon finance market, and the Alliance’s goals.

Due to the large size of the inventory database, please e-mail knowledge@cleancookstoves.org to request access to that file.

What Impedes Efficient Product Adoption - Evidence from Randomized Variation in Sales Offers for Improved Cookstoves in Uganda
Alliance Reports and Research, Gender, Other | | Released on June 10, 2012

Many people do not purchase products that appear beneficial. For example, the price of an efficient cookstove can be less than a few months’ savings on fuel. If liquidity constraints, present bias, and poor information on fuel savings and stove durability are barriers, then a novel sales offer combining a free trial, time payments, and the right to return the stove at any time should increase sales. In a randomized trial, this sales offer increases sales of an efficient charcoal-burning stove in Kampala, Uganda, from 5% to 45%. We provide additional evidence that both liquidity constraints and imperfect information were important barriers.

The Indian national initiative for advanced biomass cookstoves - the benefits of clean combustion
Alliance Reports and Research, Other | C. Venkataraman, A.D. Sagar, G. Habib, N. Lam, K.R. Smith | Released on June 10, 2012

India has recently launched the National Biomass Cookstoves Initiative (NCI) to develop next-generation cleaner biomass cookstoves and deploy them to all Indian households that currently use traditional cookstoves. The initiative has set itself the lofty aimof providing energy service comparable to clean sources such as LPG but using the same solid biomass fuels commonly used today. Such a clean energy option for the estimated 160 million Indian households nowcooking with inefficient and polluting biomass and coal cookstoves could yield enormous gains in health and welfare for the weakest and most vulnerable sections of society. At the same time, cleaner household cooking energy through substitution by advanced-combustion biomass stoves (or other options such as clean fuels) can nearly eliminate the several important products of incomplete combustion that come from today's practices and are important outdoor and greenhouse pollutants. Using national surveys, published literature and assessments, and measurements of cookstove performance solely from India, we find that about 570,000 premature deaths in poor women and children and over 4% of India's estimated greenhouse emissions could be avoided if such an initiative were in place today. These avoided emissions currently would be worth more than US$1 billion on the international carbon market. In addition, about one-third of India's black carbon emissions can be reduced alongwith a range of other health- and climate-active pollutants that affect regional air quality and climate. Although current advanced biomass stoves show substantial emissions reductions over traditional stoves, there is still additional improvement needed to reach LPG-like emission levels.We recognize that the technology development and deployment challenges tomeetNCI goals of this scale are formidable and a forthcoming companion paper focuses on what programdesign elements might best be able to overcome these challenges.

Public health benefits of strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions - overview and implications for policy makers
Health, Environment, Other | Andy Haines, Anthony J. McMichael, Kirk R. Smith, Ian Roberts, James Woodcock, Anil Markandya, Ben G. Armstrong, Diarmid Campbell-Lendrum, Alan D. Dangour, Michael Davies, Nigel Bruce, Cathryn Tonne, Mark Barrett, Paul Wilkinson | Released on June 10, 2012

This evidence provides an additional and immediate rationale for reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions beyond that of climate change mitigation alone. Climate change is an increasing and evolving threat to the health of populations worldwide. At the same time, major public health burdens remain in many regions. Climate change therefore adds further urgency to the task of addressing international health priorities, such as the UN Millennium Development Goals. Recognition that mitigation strategies can have substantial benefits for both health and climate protection offers the possibility of policy choices that are potentially both more cost effective and socially attractive than are those that address these priorities independently.

Monitoring and evaluation of improved biomass cookstove programs for indoor air quality and stove performance - conclusions from the Household Energy and Health Project
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Other | Kirk R. Smith, Karabi Dutta, Chaya Chengappa, P.P.S. Gusain, Omar Masera, Victor Berrueta, Rufus Edwards, Rob Bailis, Kyra Naumoff Shields | Released on June 10, 2012

This is a landmark report making a bridge between new scientific knowledge justifying action on SLCFs and practical measures that can be taken by countries to reduce the burden of air pollution and climate change on their sustainable development. This report identifies priority areas and sectors for action in each region with the indicative costs and benefits. It also describes the many fora where fast action could occur—regional and national air quality agreements being a case in point. This report also outlines the important role of action at the global scale and the enabling actions that could facilitate and speed up implementation of SLCF measures.

Commercialization Of Improved Cookstoves For Reduced Indoor Air Pollution In Urban Slums Of Northwest Bangladesh
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Livelihoods, Gender, Environment, Other | USAID and Winrock International | Released on June 10, 2012

Winrock, in collaboration with Concern Worldwide Bangladesh and the Village Education Resource Center (VERC), implemented the Bangladesh pilot project from 2005-2007 in selected wards Beginning in 2003, the energy team of USAID’s Bureau for Economic Growth, Agriculture, and Trade, and the environmental health team of the Bureau for Global Health jointly supported a cooperative agreement with Winrock International to develop models to reduce indoor air pollution by combining fuel-efficient cooking technologies with behavior change messages and market-based distribution mechanisms. Winrock developed two project models: a rural model piloted in the highlands of Peru for indigenous communities, and a peri-urban model piloted in Bangladesh for poor households. The objective of the pilot project was to reduce indoor air pollution and fuel consumption via the dissemination and commercialization of efficient cookstoves among peri-urban communities through an integrated and sustainable household energy intervention. The project aimed to establish a sustainable market for improved and appropriate stoves to avoid the need for subsidies, either current or future. Three models of fuel-efficient cookstoves, each significantly less polluting than traditional stoves, were selected and promoted in this project. Winrock coupled product promotion with a multi-faceted communication campaign to raise awareness about the risks of indoor smoke and the benefits of behavior change and using improved stoves to reduce IAP exposure. The project team worked with existing local government institutions and health networks to disseminate behavior change messages, and teamed up with local entrepreneurs to disseminate stoves commercially. The project has strong potential for use as a model for incorporating IAP into child survival and health programming activities, particularly those implemented by donor agencies such as the USAID/Bangladesh Mission.

Woodfuels In Kenya and Rwanda: Powering And Driving The Economy Of The Rural Areas
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Livelihoods, Gender, Environment, Other | Geoffrey Ndegwa, Dr. Thomas Breuer, Prof. Dr. Johannes Hamhaber | Released on June 10, 2012

The number of woodfuel consumers in Africa is projected to increase from around 2.5 billion in 2004 to 2.7 billion by 2030, with sub-Saharan Africa accounting for the highest increase. Rwanda and Kenya are two good examples of countries in which woodfuel plays a key role in energy provision, poverty alleviation and economic development.

2012 Budget Highlights (Government of Ghana): “Infrastructural Development for Accelerated Growth and Job Creation
Livelihoods, Other | PricewaterhouseCoopers (Ghana) Ltd. (PwC) | Released on June 10, 2012

The theme for the 2012 Budget ‘’Infrastructural Development for Accelerated Growth and Job Creation’’ is reflective of the Government of Ghana’s continuing pursuit of its ‘’Better Ghana’’ agenda. The focus of the 2012 Budget is on the provision of key infrastructure in various sectors of the economy to stimulate growth and support the private sector to create more jobs to improve the incomes of Ghanaians. It is also worth noting that Ghana has met all four convergence criteria (single digit inflation of 8.6%, external reserves of 3 months import cover, fiscal deficit excluding grants to GDP ratio of 1.9% and Central Bank financing 0%) for the West African Monetary Zone (WAMZ) as at June 2011 for the first time since the programme commenced in 2001.

Pre-Feasibility Study For An Improved Cook Stoves Project In Northern Ghana
Alliance Reports and Research, Livelihoods, Environment, Other | CARE Danmark, Danish Energy Agency, ENERGICA | Released on June 10, 2012

The overall objective of the assignment is to collect sufficient information to allow for an assessment and decision by CARE and the Danish Energy Agency on project focus and scope of a CDM Program of Activities on improved cook stoves project in Northern Ghana.

A Manual of People's Participation Towards Addressing Indoor Air Pollution in Bangladesh
Alliance Reports and Research, Gender, Other | VERC, The World Bank | Released on June 10, 2012

This manual has been developed to provide help in the planning and implementation of the proposed IAP reducing pilot initiative in respect of service delivery, capacity building of the operational staff, and empowering the user communities, local government institutions, entrepreneurs as well as the management. The manual will help presenting the participatory tools/techniques and methodologies which will be put into practice for initiation, implementation, monitoring and finally, evaluation of the pilot project. The manual is a handy package of participatory process facilitation tools/techniques that need to be conceived, understood and assimilated professionally by the users so that the actors yield the maximum output while in action.

Bangladesh Climate Change Resilience Fund: An Innovative Governance Framework
Environment, Other | BCCRF, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh | Released on June 10, 2012

The objective of BCCRF is to support the implementation of Bangladesh’s Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan for 2009-2018. The Bangladesh Government leads on the management and implementation of BCCRF. On behalf of the contributing Development Partners, and in consultation with the Government of Bangladesh, the World Bank, for a limited duration, is ensuring due diligence requirements on the BCCRF (including fiduciary management, transparency and accountability) and is ensuring projects are implemented with due regard to economy, efficiency and effectiveness.

Intra-Household Externalities And Low Demand For A New Technology Experimental Evidence On Improved Cookstoves
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Gender, Environment, Other | Grant Miller and A. Mushfiq Mobarak | Released on June 10, 2012

This paper studies the behavioral underpinnings of low demand for a technology with substantial implications for population health and the environment: improved cookstoves. We conduct a multi-pronged field experiment in rural Bangladesh to investigate two commonly-cited reasons for low demand: (1) intra-household externalities and (2) tradition-based aversion. On the former, we find that women – who bear disproportionate cooking costs – have stronger preference for improved stoves, especially health-saving stoves, but lack the authority to make purchases. On the latter, we find that revealing information about technology choices by respected community members sharing common traditions influences adoption decisions more for technologies lacking self-evident benefits and more before common experience accumulates. Overall, our findings suggest that (1) if women cannot make independent choices, public policy may not be able to exploit gender differences in preferences to promote technology adoption absent broader social change; and (2) marketing and persuasion techniques may only increase adoption temporarily and may be less effective for technologies that households can evaluate for themselves.

Indice De Marginacion Por Localidad, Capítulo 1: El concepto de marginación y su discusión
Other | CONAPO | Released on June 10, 2012

Part 1 of a document that addresses the concept of marginalization from different points of view in an effort to understand the definition of marginalization and how it is measured. The first part includes different concepts of exclusion and marginalization and establishes the relationship between poverty, exclusion and marginalization. It emphasizes the effect of marginalization on democracy and participation, and emphasize importance of measuring and tracking marginalization for the design of public and social policy.

Improving Indoor Air Quality For Poor Families: A Controlled Experiment In Bangladesh
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Environment, Other | Susmita Dasgupta, Mainul Huq, M. Khaliquzzaman, David Wheeler | Released on June 10, 2012

The World Health Organization’s 2004 Global and Regional Burden of Disease Report estimates that acute respiratory infections from indoor air pollution (pollution from burning wood, animal dung, and other bio-fuels) kill a million children annually in developing countries, inflicting a particularly heavy toll on poor families in South Asia and Africa. This paper reports on an experiment that studied the use of construction materials, space configurations, cooking locations, and household ventilation practices (use of doors and windows) as potentially-important determinants of indoor air pollution. Results from controlled experiments in Bangladesh are analyzed to test whether changes in these determinants can have significant effects on indoor air pollution. Analysis of the data shows, for example, that pollution from the cooking area diffuses into living spaces rapidly and completely. Furthermore, it is important to factor in the interaction between outdoor and indoor air pollution. Among fuels, seasonal conditions seem to affect the relative severity of pollution from wood, dung, and other biomass fuels. However, there is no ambiguity about their collective impact. All are far dirtier than clean fuels. The analysis concludes that if cooking with clean fuels is not possible, then building the kitchen with porous construction material and providing proper ventilation in cooking areas will yield a better indoor health environment.

Energy And Sustainable Development In Bangladesh
Livelihoods, Other | Ijaz Hossain, M. Tamim | Released on June 10, 2012

Bangladesh’s situation is typical of most developing countries, i.e., additional funds to pursue sustainable development are not available even though decision makers may be aware of the correct strategy. The scarcity of resources can become so critical that in many cases a path contrary to that of sustainable development is followed. Often policy makers do not understand the implications of the development path they are pursuing. Capacity building of government agencies therefore is essential in charting a sustainable energy development path.

Ghana: EnterpriseWorks/VITA – Gyapa Charcoal and Wood Stoves
Alliance Reports and Research, Other | EnterpriseWorks/VITA, Shell Foundation | Released on June 10, 2012

EnterpriseWorks/VITA is promoting a Kenyan sourced alternative called the Gyapa (meaning ‘good fire’) stove which is produced in three sizes. A ceramic liner improves fuel-efficiency by up to 50% and the stoves are marketed with the slogan ‘it’s already cooked’. This article describes the program and related marketing campaign.

Ghana Country Environmental Analysis
Livelihoods, Environment, Other | Gobind Nananki, Mats Karlsson, John McIntire, Mary Barton-Dock, Jean-Christophe Carret, Muthukumara Mani | Released on June 10, 2012

The Ghana Country Environment Analysis (CEA) has been formulated to assist the Government of Ghana and its development partners to: (a) assess the country’s environmental priorities, the environmental implications of key economic and sector policies, and the country’s institutional capacity to address them; and (b) find practical management, institutional, and policy solutions to handle issues of natural resource management, environmental degradation, and sustainability of growth. The two main outputs of this CEA are (a) a comprehensive report that provides—for each sector/asset—an overview of the sector and its contribution to growth, an analysis of the underlying causes of degradation (with a specific focus on policy, regulatory, and institutional issues and applying public expenditure review as an analytical tool), and a set of implementable recommendations to address these issues; and (b) a set of policy/action matrixes that provide—for each sector/asset—a road map for action in the short, medium, and long-term. Whenever possible, these matrixes are accompanied by financial matrixes that identify the financial requirements for and financial gaps in the implementation of the proposed actions.

Ghana In Figures 2008
Livelihoods, Other | Ghana Statistical Service (GSS) | Released on June 10, 2012

Ghana in Figures” is an annual publication by which the Ghana Statistical Service (GSS) satisfies the needs of the general public, and more generally promotes the goal of enhancing the effectiveness of policy-making. Selected basic indicators on demographic and socio-economic conditions in Ghana intended to provide a quick statistical reference on the country are presented in the handbook.

Ghana Microfinance Institutions Network (GHAMFIN) Report on Microfinance Institutions (MFIs)
Livelihoods, Other | GHAMFIN | Released on June 10, 2012

This report follows closely the format for the two previous GHAMFIN reports on MFIs, with the addition of a chapter that has been added to compare the data for the institutions in the northern half of the country with the national benchmarks, as requested and supported by SPEED Ghana, a GTZ / DANIDA project. The three northern regions are the most deprived and poorest in the country. Only 11 out of the 125 Rural and Community Banks in the country are in these three regions. Chapter 4 of this report deals with outreach performance based on the entire population of MFIs, which supply quarterly outreach data to their apex bodies or to GHAMFIN for aggregation and submission to the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning. Chapters 5-7 analyse the performance benchmarks for the financial structure and performance, revenues, expenses, efficiencies/productivity and portfolio quality.

Household Cookstoves, Environment, Health, And Climate Change: A New Look At An Old Problem
Alliance Reports and Research, Health, Livelihoods, Gender, Environment, Other | Daniel M. Kammen | Released on June 10, 2012

Household Cookstoves, Environment, Health, and Climate Change: A New Look at an Old Problem takes stock of our collective knowledge of actions and opportunities centered on clean stoves. The report not only examines the lessons learned in specific stove campaigns; it builds the case for a multisectoral approach to understand the effects of stove policies and programs. After reviewing the state of cookstove research and action, the report takes a welcome and much needed look at the potential “game changers” associated with cookstoves. It examines opportunities for technology development, leading to the availability of “advanced” biomass stoves; new sources and mechanisms of financing, including those linked to climate change; and the formation of new international coalitions and partnerships like the GACC. Based on these assessments, the report makes a compelling case for the WBG’s re-engagement in the development community on many dimensions of a field that can benefit most from the reach, lessons sharing, and practical focus that a multinational development agency can offer.

The Associated Programme On Flood Management Case Study - Bangladesh Flood Management
Environment, Other | A.N.H. Akhtar Hossain | Released on June 10, 2012

Bangladesh is one of the most flood prone countries in the world, which is situated in south Asian sub-continent. A location map of Bangladesh is given in fig. 1. Because of its unique geographical location and to1pography, flood of different magnitudes and types occurs every year. During the last half century at least 8 nos. of extreme flood events occurred affecting 50% of land area. Since early sixties of the last century the country has adopted different kinds of measures for flood management with mixed experiences.

Final Report On Technical Study Of Biogas Plants Installed In Bangladesh
Alliance Reports and Research, Livelihoods, Gender, Environment, Other | Prakash C. Ghimire, Development Partners - Nepal | Released on June 10, 2012

The overall objective of the proposed study was to conduct a technical review of existing biogas plants constructed across Bangladesh over the past years to facilitate the preparation of implementation plan for the proposed National Domestic Biogas Programme. The field study was carried out during the period September 03 to October 09, 2005 in 72 randomly sampled biogas households from eight different districts representing all the six divisions in Bangladesh. These plants were installed by BCSIR (61 nos.), LGED (7 nos.) and GS (5 nos.) during the period 1997 to 2005. Analysis and interpretation of the result have been done with the data and information from only 66 households as the six plants were feared to be outliers.

Final Report - Sanitation Review
Alliance Reports and Research, Gender, Other | VERC and Winrock International | Released on June 10, 2012

While appreciating that the issue of indoor air quality has, in recent years, emerged as a major health concern in both the developed and the developing countries of the world, the World Bank in collaboration with the Government of Bangladesh (GoB) undertook and accomplished the necessary task of attempting a Bangladesh Country Environment Analysis (CEA), a major finding of which study also convincingly pointed at the dire fact that majority people in the country living in the rural areas are putting up with poor indoor air quality only because they are continuing with the traditional cooking practices. The study also found that the indoor air pollution (IAP) exposure risks can also be mitigated by the villagers at feasible cost, if self interest motivates them, and they are convinced that the problems are serious, like problems and diseases caused by poor sanitation and bad hygiene practices. As the community led total sanitation (CLTS) approach ignited people to undertake sanitation programme at their own initiative, for own good, based on community organizations and own resources, supported and facilitated by the NGOs and LGIs, the IAP risks can also be mitigated with community-led approach through an integrated institutional arrangement (GO-LGIs-NGOs-CBOs and Private sector) and effective financial policy from the government and donor communities.

Fuel-Efficient Stove Programs In Humanitarian Settings: An Implementer’S Toolkit
Alliance Reports and Research, Other | Academy for Educational Development (AED), USAID | Released on June 10, 2012

There is much debate over what types and styles of stoves are the most fuel-efficient and user-friendly, and whether a particular stove will be useful to displaced populations. The purpose of this Toolkit is to help humanitarian organizations determine if an FES program is feasible and appropriate for a given setting, and if so, how to design and implement an effective program for wood-burning stoves. These guidelines and associated tools represent standard good practices approved by the United States Agency for International Development/Office of U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance (USAID/OFDA) for FES programs in immediate and protracted humanitarian contexts.

Report of the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) of the Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy (GPRS)
Health, Livelihoods, Environment, Other | Jonathan A. Allotey, Professor George Gyan-Baffour | Released on June 10, 2012

The report illustrates that environmental management is essential to economic growth and poverty reduction. Environment is inextricably linked to social, cultural, natural resource, institutional and economic issues. This is not adequately addressed in the current edition of the GPRS. The SEA process has helped all participants to understand the wider impacts of policies plans and programmes on the environment, economic growth and poverty reduction. The SEA of the GPRS has involved a wide range of stakeholders as evidenced by the endorsement of the process by 27 MDAs 108 district assemblies, parliamentary representatives, civil society, NGOs the Bank of Ghana and business associates.

Draft Bioenergy Policy For Ghana
Alliance Reports and Research, Livelihoods, Other | Government of Ghana, Energy Commission | Released on June 10, 2012

Biomass energy is likely to continue to dominate as a prime energy source in Ghana. This phenomenon, together with the steady development of biofuels as the emerging fuel, has spurred the interest and need to ensure the sustainable supply of bioenergy. This policy paper, which is in five chapters, addresses the policy issues and recommendations for achieving the overall objectives of the Government in ensuring sustainability of the bioenergy sector. Chapter one is devoted to woodfuels and chapter two dwells on biofuels. Chapter three and chapter four cover energy from biogas waste and electricity from biomass respectively while the fifth and final chapter concludes with a summary of the implementation programme.

Gender and Community Development Analysis In Rwanda
Health, Livelihoods, Gender, Other | Republic of Rwanda, East African Community | Released on June 10, 2012

The importance of mainstreaming gender in any country’s development initiatives and the need to monitor and evaluate the progress of the mechanism is premised on the alarming global gender disparities in social and economic opportunities, property and rights. On several occasions, the Government of Rwanda (GoR) has, through its stands and actions, demonstrated its commitment to work towards the reduction of gender-based inequalities and promotion of gender equality and equity in all areas. Rwanda adopted the Beijing Platform for Action and undertook strategic actions aimed at tackling twelve identified crucial areas. It ratified and adhered to a number of international and regional conventions, charters and declarations, including, the CEDAW, the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), the United Nations Security Council Resolution 1325, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 10 December 1948, the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD), Southern African Development Community (SADC), COMESA and among others . All these instruments highlight gender as an important approach for sustainable development. By ratifying the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), in November 1981, Rwanda undertook to take appropriate measures, including legislation to fight any act or practice of discrimination against women, to modify and/or abolish existing laws, regulations, customs and practices which embody discrimination against women as discussed in the next section.